Showing posts with label FIRST. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FIRST. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

The Collaboration Paradox

Quintessential article from John Abele concerning collaboration now available, called "The Collaboration Paradox..." It examines the necessity for collaboration - no surprises there - and why it is, if we accept that collaboration is often a necessity, we can be so bad at it or resist it so much. A few reasons are that we are conditioned to excel independently, and that we don't afford collaborations enough foresight or strategy. John does a better job of explaining it than I can, so I'll leave the rest to the article.

The Kingbridge reason for being is founded on this need for improved approaches to collaborations. The Kingbridge philosophy is founded on the methods John has influenced and learned from over the years, which he references in this article.

The article is available through XConomy, an interesting study in collaboration unto itself. It's an exceptional blog with exceptional content, from a whole slew of guest authors. It's not totally opensourced or crowdsourced, as the articles are edited/policed, and the editors do contribute. A successful middle ground.

Friday, March 28, 2008

FIRST, the second

The first day of actual tournament play at the GTA FIRST Regional is done, and it was just incredible. I could go on about the kids and their gracious professionalism, which is under documented, but I'll instead focus on a very small portion of the behind the scenes adult collaboration.

My role there is as a judge. There are nearly 20 of us. Each of the rest is my senior and infinitely more wise and accredited. They are all keen to mentor and very welcoming though, so it was a very positive learning experience for me. We have to interview teams and assign awards for such things as gracious professionalism, entrepreneurial activity, and efforts/successes in advancing the FIRST values and the profile of the engineering profession with youth. Not only is this all somewhat subjective, but there are many more complexities.

Among the complexities is the fact that every judge cohort interviews only a fraction of the teams before presenting their suggestions for winners to the rest. It's easy to fall in love with the teams and feel a bias for the team that you brought forth, as their fate is in your hands. Despite this and other confidential matters, the selection process for the day 1 awards went very well. This is in large part due to moderation and good intentions.

The judge advisor is University of Waterloo's Rob Gorbet. One would expect that he's an engaging presenter, but he is also a masterful facilitator. He exceeds every judge in terms of knowledge of the teams, but manages to reserve his input and not lead the group. He is great at asking questions to clarify and ensure that we are following the purpose and criteria appropriately. A good moderator is a marvelous addition to a meeting.

The "good intentions" come from the judges and everyone at FIRST. While we can feel an inclination to act in the interests of the teams we nominated, we ultimately all want what's best for the kids, and the deserving winner is what's best. Coming to consensus in this group was never a compromise, but rather was a truly collaborative process. Some good debate and our complete commitment to making the right decision, but nothing uncomfortable for anyone.

Why can decision making be so difficult in other situations? These were not simple decisions we were making. Could it be that less pure intentions and objectives influence the quality of the process by their impact on motives?

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

In the Presence of Greatness


There's something profoundly humbling about standing in a room full of several hundered or several thousand teenagers that are all smarter than you are. It's amplified when they're WAY smarter than you, as is my situation when I find myself at FIRST Robotics events (For Inspiration and Recognition of Science and Technology). The accompanying picture is of the 2007 Chairman's Award Winners, pictured with - among others - FIRST Creator Dean Kamen, Chairman John Abele, and a politician that should feel very humbled indeed.


What's the relevance to this blog? Well, clearly we have teams of kids working together, but it's bigger than that. There are no limits to what I could learn from these kids about science, technology, math, etc, etc, etc. But it's the superior approach to collaboration that the game's rules and kids' nature that astonishes me the most. The most successful teams don't only build robots that would put Number 5 to shame, but they also are the most effective collaborators. And not in the typical, overhyped and overdefined corporate way of effective teamwork, or strategic alliance with complimentors. The successful FIRST teams have come to realize that collaborating with competitors is equally as important.

As with the marketplace, and the world, FIRST is not a zero-sum game. Scoring and rules as with ubiquitous incentives in many aspects of life favour "coopetition" over competition. The greatest honour in FIRST, the Chairman's Award, is not given to the winner of the competition necessarily either. Rather, the grand prize is reserved for the team that has displayed the FIRST values most thoroughly and effectively. The core value has got to be "Gracious Professionalism", which has a few interpretations. The best description I've heard of Gracious Professionalism is:

"Behave like your grandmother is always watching you, and you are competing with her other grandchildren."

I'll be judging at the largest regional FIRST competition in the world at The Hershey Center in Mississauga from March 27-29. If you can make it, do make it, and prepare to be inspired.